If we could design the perfect graphics program after testing all these products, what would it look like and what features might it have?
Useful wizards for easy image editing, import/export, and manipulation
A method of easily downloading images from a site
An integrated image browser or straightforward external one
A great GIF/JPG optimizer
Live editable type
Dozens of Web-related effects
3D capabilities
Simple animation creation and editing
Support for layers and PNG files
With all that in mind, is there any perfect program that stands out above all the rest? Not really. Some of these come agonizingly close, but when we reach for one tool or the other depending on what we have to accomplish, it becomes clear that none of these tools has absolutely everything. The best thing is that we didn't really find a clunker in the bunch...they're all good, solid tools.
Top Winners
Still, we did find some winners:
Macromedia Fireworks:
This comprehensive tool can do just about everything, and will especially appeal to professional graphics designers. Fireworks doesn't have half the learning curve of Photoshop, yet rivals it for sheer power (and beats it for Web-related work). The new slicing, tweening, and JavaScript rollover features might be worth the price alone.
Ulead PhotoImpact:
If you're on a budget, don't spend all of your time tweaking pixels, or don't want to, we can't think of any better way to spend $100 on a graphics program. The SmartSaver becomes part of your Explorer menu, and the effects, button and background designers match or beat any of the other products tested. Highly recommended.
Micrografx Webtricity:
Picture Publisher, the main attraction in this quartet of tools, has professional features like Fireworks and wizards and ease of use like Photoimpact, as well as some all its own such as Light Studio. Simply 3D has its own wizards, so you don't have to be a full-time artist to create serious 3D scenes as GIF animations or VRML. Windows Draw is a vector program, to help round out the offering. If this package was integrated a bit better, Micrografx might have the top honors here, but there's very little you can't do with these programs.
Database Journal: The Knowledge Center for Database Professionals
and find truth, justice, and a clue or two.
